Francis's Slap At Cardinal Sarah. Behind the Scenes

Settimo Cielo | 10/26/2017 | Staff
Click For Photo: http://www.repstatic.it/cless/channel/espresso/2013-v1/img/lespresso800-200.png

The letter with which Francis recently contradicted and humiliated Cardinal Robert Sarah, prefect of the congregation for divine worship, is the latest proof of how this pope exercises his magisterium.

When Francis wants to introduce innovations, he never does so in clear and distinct words. He prefers to open discussions, to set “processes” in motion, within which the innovations are gradually affirmed.

Example - Amoris - Laetitia - Interpretations - Applications

The most glaring example is “Amoris Laetitia,” for which contrasting interpretations and applications are in fact given, with entire episcopates lining up on one or the other side.

And when he is asked for clarification, he refuses. As in the case of the five “dubia” submitted to him by four cardinals, not deemed worthy of so much as a reply.

Cardinal - Sarah - Authority - Role - Responsibilities

But when a cardinal like Sarah, an authority by role and responsibilities, weighs in to give a papal motu proprio on the liturgy the only interpretation he sees as correct and therefore to be implemented by the congregation of which he is prefect, Francis does not remain silent but reacts with harshness, in defense of those passages of the motu prorio - which in effect are anything but clear - that contain the liberalizations dear to him.

This is just what has happened in recent days.

Recapitulate - September - Francis - Motu - Proprio

Let’s recapitulate. On September 9 Francis publishes the motu proprio “Magnum Principium” concerning the adaptations and translations into contemporary languages of the liturgical texts of the Latin Church.

In defining the role of the congregation for divine worship concerning the adaptations and translations of the liturgical texts prepared by the national episcopal conferences and submitted for the approval of the Holy See, the motu proprio distinguishes between “recognitio” and “confirmatio,” between review and confirmation.

Distinction - Means - Clarity - Fact - Sides

But the distinction is by no means explained with clarity. And in fact, two sides took shape immediately among the experts.

There are those who maintain that...
(Excerpt) Read more at: Settimo Cielo
Wake Up To Breaking News!
You've go to put up with Free Speech to have Free Speech!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!