Should women serve as clergy, especially among Protestants? Why, or why not?

GetReligion | 8/10/2017 | Richard Ostling
iceyy (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo: http://static1.squarespace.com/static/52c2df7ae4b0d215dded86fd/536fab69e4b00b0fd2515399/597b7830914e6b7dd5bb7a68/1502409054130/ReligionGuyQ%26A.png?format=1000w

THE RELIGION GUY (instead of answering a question posted by a reader) raises this topic that he discussed with a house guest who advocated an all-male clergy on biblical grounds, while The Guy (full disclosure) favored having pastors of either gender.

Most Christians have belonged to church bodies that limit clergy leadership to men. A watershed occurred in 1975 when Archbishop of Canterbury Donald Coggan wrote to inform Pope Paul VI about a growing consensus within the international Anglican Communion in favor of allowing women priests.

Response - Paul - Catholic - Church - Change

In response, Paul stated that the Catholic Church believes this change is “not admissible” due to: (1) Jesus Christ’s choosing of only male apostles. (2) “The constant practice of the church” from the apostles onward to follow Jesus’s example. (3) The consistent belief of Catholicism’s “living teaching authority” that male priesthood fits “God’s plan for his Church.”

The following year, a 5,500-word explanation from the Vatican’s doctrinal office, approved by Paul VI, called this tenet “immutable” and “normative." It argued that even Jesus’s mother Mary did not hold “apostolic ministry” despite her “incomparable role,” and that the women who worked closely with the Apostle Paul weren’t ordained either.

Section - Mass - Role - Christ - Point

A separate section said the priest celebrating Mass takes “the role of Christ, to the point of being his very image,” having a “natural resemblance” that’s difficult to see with a woman. However, this was not considered a “demonstrative argument” that defines Catholic theology.

Pope John Paul II issued a 1994 apostolic letter to all bishops that summarized those prior documents and reaffirmed “the constant and universal Tradition of the Church." Furthermore, John Paul declared that “all doubt” should be removed on such a “matter of great importance” and that “this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful.”

Orthodox - Christianity - Tradition

Orthodox Christianity holds to the same unbroken tradition, holding that...
(Excerpt) Read more at: GetReligion
11 other people are viewing this story
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!

LongRoom Culture
Grizzly Bear Cubs Wrestling At Katmai National Park in Alaska! Cubs will be cubs, and these bears are having a great time...
SpaceX Landing Looked Insanely Easy! The return to earth for the latest SpaceX mission was a perfect landing.  On August 14,...
Fire and Dominoes? These domino set ups by Kaplamino feature candles, sparklers and balloons to create an exciting array of...
WOW! Dynjandi Waterfall in Iceland is Amazing! Iceland is an amazing magical place!  This series of waterfalls is massive and...
Baby Elephant Rescued by Female Elephant While Surrounded by Lions Just Waiting For The Rescue To Fail! Another example of the...
Russian Mother Cat Adopts 8 Orphaned Hedgehog Babies! When these hedgehog babies lost their mother in a lawnmower accident, the...
Funny Hamster Running On Wheel With Friend Gets Caught And Hit With The Wheel On The Rear Until He Breaks Free!
Captain Jumped Into Frigid Waters To Rescue Crew Members Of The Capsized Fishing Boat The Grayling! When Captain Pruitt of the...
Dog Says Thank You To Owner! Can dogs really talk?  There are so many examples of dogs saying things that we understand, it is...
Storm The Golden Retriever Rescues A Baby Deer From Drowning! A true hero, Storm and his owner, Mark Freeley were walking along...
Time Lapse Of Orb Spider Spinning Web! Orb spiders are amazing web spinners and this one is captured creating its masterpiece...
Longboarding In The Alps With Metal Sliding Gloves! This amazing run down a steep road really shows how the gloves are used.
Knife Cutting Through Wood Like Butter! Wood carving takes very sharp tools!  This carver shows how he is holding the spoon in...
Man Jumps From Trampoline Into A Giant Inflated Bubble Ball! Complete with somersault, this man jumps from the trampoline to...
Dog Runs Along The Beach With Kite Boarder! It doesn't look like this kite boarder expected to have such close company on his...
Waterfall Unable to "Fall" Due To High Winds! Unusual video of a waterfall that is being blown by the wind so severely that it...
Little Cowboy Learning Calf Roping At Just The Right Age! When the calf breaks out of the chute, this little cowboy is ready.
Dog Shadows Every Move That His Owner Makes! This dog couldn't be happier than to make every move that his owner makes at the...
Fun Physics Tricks You Can Try At Home! These physics tricks are great experiments to try at home just for fun! Here's another...
Life Hacks That Will Help You Organize Your Clothes! This collection of tips and tricks in organizing your closet and drawers...
Cat Can Play Shell Game Flawlessly! This con game does not con this cat who can pick the right cup everytime!  The cat would be...
Mother Grizzly Carries Her 2 Cubs Across River On Her Back! This touching video shows a mother grizzly swimming across the...
Darwin's Bark Spider Has Real "Spidey" Power And Builds Bridge Over 80 Feet Long! This spider is able to extrude a strand of...
Dance Meets Light Show - Light Balance Dancers at America's Got Talent 2017! This dance routine is amazing. It is...
Mouse Doesn't Let Being Upside Down and Under His Running Wheel Stop Him From Getting a Good Run In! Something is not right in...