‘Why hasn’t Governor Cuomo been excommunicated?’

The Deacon's Bench | 1/23/2019 | Staff
marika (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo: https://wp-media.patheos.com/blogs/sites/56/2019/01/Andrew_Cuomo_2016_crop.jpg

That question has been a recurring refrain over the last several days—and grew louder after yesterday’s action, signing into law a sweeping bill that essentially allows abortion at any time, even to the last trimester.

Cuomo’s own bishop slammed the law in the strongest terms.

Cuomo - Catholic - Pols - Abortion

But some think he has not gone far enough. So they ask: Why hasn’t Cuomo (and other Catholic pols who support abortion) been excommunicated?

A few years ago, canon lawyer Ed Peters addressed that:

Excommunication - Pro-abortion - Politicians - Law - Way

To those wanting the immediate excommunication of pro-abortion politicians, I have to say that canon law simply does not read that way. To make a long story short, an excommunication for abortion has to be linked to a specific abortion and, given the structure of American government and medical institutions, one simply can’t link a given legislator’s vote with a specific abortion within the limits of causality recognized by canon law. Now, I like to think that the words of law generally mean what they say. If we distort the words of penal canon law to the degree necessary to make legislators fall within the present terms of the abortion canon, we would do violence to the text of the law, and that’s always bad; distortions...
(Excerpt) Read more at: The Deacon's Bench
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!