Weekly Meanderings, 12 January 2019

Jesus Creed | 1/12/2019 | Staff
tiazanne (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo: https://wp-media.patheos.com/blogs/sites/40/2019/01/Screen-Shot-2019-01-09-at-7.29.19-PM.png

Seven books to consult at once!

A new blog and an exceptional post by David Cramer:

Case - Month - Bit - Dust-up - Religion

In case you missed it, last month there was a bit of a blogosphere dust-up when religion writer Jonathan Merritt tweeted that it was “weird” that evangelical historian Thomas Kidd used the word “evangelical” to describe Phillis Wheatley, the first published African-American poet.

A number of evangelical historians came to Kidd’s defense (as is well documented by historian John Fea), and the conversation quickly shifted to the questions of how to define “evangelicalism” and who should do it.

Conversation - Amusement - Time - Merritt - Book

I followed this conversation with some amusement because I was at the same time reading Merritt’s latest book, Learning to Speak God from Scratch, where he argues that Christians should be liberated to play with religious words to breathe new life into them, and he notes that the advent of dictionaries and their seemingly rigid and prescriptive definitions have hindered our ability to do so.

In light of the argument of his book, Merritt’s insistence that Kidd use the word “evangelical” in conformity with his seemingly prescriptive definition seemed a bit—for lack of a better word—weird.

Merritt - Approach - Book - Word - Word

If Merritt had applied the approach of his book to the word “evangelical,” I think he would have seen how the word, like many religious words, has morphed and evolved over time and is used in different ways based on its context. There’s no Platonic essence of evangelicalism, but rather, as Wittgenstein argues in Philosophical Investigations, the meaning of a word is found in its use.

While Merritt is correct that it would be weird to consider Wheatley an evangelical in certain times and contexts, Kidd’s use of the term is quite appropriate relative to the time and context he was describing.

Merritt - Defense - Word

In Merritt’s defense, it has become nearly, might we say, useless to use the word “evangelical”...
(Excerpt) Read more at: Jesus Creed
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Tagged:
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!