The Times Pushes a Tired and Flawed Gay Priest Narrative

Crisis Magazine | 2/21/2019 | Adrian Reimers
cv2angelscv2angels (Posted by) Level 3
Click For Photo:

In its recent Sunday edition, America’s newspaper of record ran a front-page article on the challenges facing gay Catholic priests titled “A Silent Crisis for Gay Priests.” It is the most recent specimen of the journalistic genre, suffering-gay-Catholic-priests-in-an-unwelcoming-church. The narrative is well-known by now: a Church that fails to welcome gay priests, a Church whose leaders may well reject them, a Church where they must stay in the closet has made their ‘closet’ into a cage. This narrative has been developed on the pages of the New York Times, America Magazine, and Fr. James Martin’s book.

This article is flawed. The narrative is false. The flaw is that this and other such articles do not address Catholicism, not really. In fact, this popular narrative badly misunderstands both the Catholic Church and the priest himself.

Priest - Gay - God - Factors - Influences

Who is the priest? He may identify as “gay,” but this is not what God made him to be. Because of genetic or psychological factors, or perhaps some other influences, his neuronal networks or hormonal balance may cause him to find other men sexually desirable. Like every other human being he is embodied, and our bodily appetites are frequently disordered or misdirected. More important, however, is that he has a rational soul, and in virtue of that soul he can know truths and desire the good. It is in virtue of the soul that he is what he is and becomes who he is to be. The priest is a man.

The priest is also baptized, joined permanently to Christ as a member of his body. From his mother’s womb he has been called to God the Father. The point of his life is union with God—that is, holiness. Therefore, he (and indeed, every Christian) is called to chastity, without which mature, self-giving love is impossible. That he may...
(Excerpt) Read more at: Crisis Magazine
Wake Up To Breaking News!
Settled law: one party can't change a contract. Now if the Government, citizens and the Consstitution...
Sign In or Register to comment.

Welcome to Long Room!

Where The World Finds Its News!